HP discussion

Ok, so we were discussing with Tomogirl about certain characters of Harry Potter and their worth.

For example, Fred is deffinitely necessary alongside George as a comic relief, given that the late part of the books is always so dramatic. And his demise is really tragic for everyone.

Snape, on the other hand, was always mean, sour and devious. He always tried to find an excuse to atack the people he disliked, whether they deserved it or not. He never tried to understand others or be nice to anyone. It simply wasn't part of his personality. There are many fans who support the evil characters because they think they might be tragic characters yet redeemable.

I dissagree in this respect. There are certain personality traits that make a person. Even those can be changed. But when someone chooses to continue being the way they are, despite showing them other possibilities, then that person doesn't want to be redeemed.

So, to make it easier, I opened this discussion for all the characters you want to put. And I'll begin by copying here Tomogirl's post.